Hospitality Insurance Online :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council?w=400
An Australian court recently ruled in favour of the City of Joondalup, rejecting a negligence claim lodged by an injured e-scooter rider.
The Western Australia District Court found the city not liable for an accident involving insurance broker Kirstin Leibbrandt, who collided with a fence post while riding an e-scooter in the Perth suburb of Hillarys.

The court's decision came after Ms Leibbrandt argued that the city had been negligent in situating fence posts too close to the pathway, in defiance of the Austroads Guide to Road Design. Conversely, the city defended its stance, suggesting the incident was a result of Ms Leibbrandt's carelessness while navigating her e-scooter. Judge Alan Troy dismissed her claim, citing that although the risk was foreseeable and not insignificant, it remained minimal for anyone exercising reasonable care.

The accident occurred as Ms Leibbrandt moved to the left to accommodate a cyclist passing from behind, striking a fence post and injuring her wrist. Judge Troy noted her speed of approximately 20-25 km/h on a straight stretch of shared pathway was excessive, contributing to the mishap. The city's defence highlighted that Ms Leibbrandt steered her scooter into the pole during daylight, reiterating that the responsibility lay on the rider's actions.

In its ruling, the court outlined that the Austroads guide, heavily relied upon by Ms Leibbrandt for her case, serves as a general framework rather than a strict mandate. Judge Troy emphasised that road authorities could adapt practices based on local conditions and policies, thus negating negligence claims solely based on deviations from such guidelines.

This verdict underscores the legal principle that local councils are not inherently liable for every accident occurring within public spaces. However, a commentary from law firm Hall & Wilcox advises that authorities should continually evaluate potential hazards, adequately document decisions, and refer to established standards. The judgment endorses a pragmatic approach to public safety, where reasonable measures are expected rather than absolute perfection.

Legal experts suggest this case will likely influence future claims of this nature, potentially shaping how liability is assessed in similar circumstances involving public infrastructure and shared pathways.

Published:Monday, 14th Jul 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Transforming Home Insurance: The Rise of the Home Energy Revolution Transforming Home Insurance: The Rise of the Home Energy Revolution
17 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The landscape of home insurance policies in Australia stands on the brink of transformation as an increasing number of homes, apartment complexes, and small businesses are projected to integrate solar panels and battery systems by 2050. According to a report from the actuarial consultancy Finity, these homes will evolve into independent power stations, generating and storing their own electricity, marking a pivotal shift in home energy management. - read more
Life Insurers Reevaluate Amid Rising Mental Health Claims Life Insurers Reevaluate Amid Rising Mental Health Claims
16 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

In a growing industry concern, the Council of Australian Life Insurers has highlighted an alarming increase in mental health-related claims, which are now the leading cause of total and permanent disability (TPD) claims. The rise has driven insurers to reconsider their current practices and strategies to address this trend. - read more
QBE Highlights the Importance of Adequate Landlord Insurance QBE Highlights the Importance of Adequate Landlord Insurance
15 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

Landlords in Australia have been advised by QBE Insurance Group to reassess their insurance coverage, following survey findings that indicate many could encounter financial hardships if their rental operations are interrupted. According to QBE's data, 38% of landlords might face financial challenges should their properties become uninhabitable or rental payments cease for a duration of two to six weeks. - read more
Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council
14 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

An Australian court recently ruled in favour of the City of Joondalup, rejecting a negligence claim lodged by an injured e-scooter rider. The Western Australia District Court found the city not liable for an accident involving insurance broker Kirstin Leibbrandt, who collided with a fence post while riding an e-scooter in the Perth suburb of Hillarys. - read more
Mental Health Surpasses Other Causes in TPD Claims, Doubling Payouts Over Five Years Mental Health Surpasses Other Causes in TPD Claims, Doubling Payouts Over Five Years
14 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

Recent findings from the Council of Australian Life Insurers (CALI) reveal that mental health issues have become the primary cause of Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) claims. Insurers disbursed nearly twice the amount for such claims in 2024 compared to five years prior. This data originates from the CALI and KPMG's Cause of Claims Results Report, highlighting a significant shift in the nature of insurance claims. - read more


Hospitality Insurance Articles

What Hospitality Business Owners Need to Know About Income Protection Insurance What Hospitality Business Owners Need to Know About Income Protection Insurance
The Australian hospitality industry is renowned for its vibrancy, yet it also faces significant challenges. With fluctuating demand, seasonal changes, and unpredictable external factors such as economic downturns and pandemics, hospitality businesses often operate in a high-risk environment. For hotel operators, the stakes are even higher due to substantial investments in property, staff, and customer service. - read more
Understanding Hospitality Insurance: Considerations for Aussie Business Owners Understanding Hospitality Insurance: Considerations for Aussie Business Owners
Hospitality insurance is a crucial component for businesses within the hospitality sector, offering coverage for a range of incidents that could potentially derail operations. It's designed to protect establishments like hotels, restaurants, and event venues from various risks such as liability claims, property damage, and interruption of services. - read more
Tips for Finding the Best Hospitality Insurance Coverage Tips for Finding the Best Hospitality Insurance Coverage
Tailored insurance is a type of insurance policy that's specifically designed to meet the unique needs of a particular business or industry. Unlike one-size-fits-all policies, tailored insurance provides a more customized approach, ensuring that the coverage fits the specific risks and requirements of the business. - read more
Why Tailored Insurance is Essential for Your Hospitality Business Why Tailored Insurance is Essential for Your Hospitality Business
In the bustling world of hospitality, the right insurance can make all the difference for your business. Tailored insurance, as the name suggests, involves customising your insurance policy to meet the specific needs and risks associated with your industry. This personalised approach ensures that you are not overpaying for unnecessary coverage while also safeguarding your business against potential threats. - read more
Essential Insurance Types Every Cafe Owner Should Consider Essential Insurance Types Every Cafe Owner Should Consider
Running a cafe is more than just serving delightful coffee and snacks; it's about creating an experience and ensuring that experience is safeguarded. While the hospitality industry can be incredibly rewarding, it's not without its risks. This is where the importance of insurance comes into play, acting as a crucial safety net for cafe owners. - read more
Why Tailored Insurance is Essential for Your Hospitality Business Why Tailored Insurance is Essential for Your Hospitality Business
In the bustling world of hospitality, the right insurance can make all the difference for your business. Tailored insurance, as the name suggests, involves customising your insurance policy to meet the specific needs and risks associated with your industry. This personalised approach ensures that you are not overpaying for unnecessary coverage while also safeguarding your business against potential threats. - read more
Tips for Finding the Best Hospitality Insurance Coverage Tips for Finding the Best Hospitality Insurance Coverage
Tailored insurance is a type of insurance policy that's specifically designed to meet the unique needs of a particular business or industry. Unlike one-size-fits-all policies, tailored insurance provides a more customized approach, ensuring that the coverage fits the specific risks and requirements of the business. - read more
Understanding Hospitality Insurance: Considerations for Aussie Business Owners Understanding Hospitality Insurance: Considerations for Aussie Business Owners
Hospitality insurance is a crucial component for businesses within the hospitality sector, offering coverage for a range of incidents that could potentially derail operations. It's designed to protect establishments like hotels, restaurants, and event venues from various risks such as liability claims, property damage, and interruption of services. - read more
What Hospitality Business Owners Need to Know About Income Protection Insurance What Hospitality Business Owners Need to Know About Income Protection Insurance
The Australian hospitality industry is renowned for its vibrancy, yet it also faces significant challenges. With fluctuating demand, seasonal changes, and unpredictable external factors such as economic downturns and pandemics, hospitality businesses often operate in a high-risk environment. For hotel operators, the stakes are even higher due to substantial investments in property, staff, and customer service. - read more
Essential Insurance Types Every Cafe Owner Should Consider Essential Insurance Types Every Cafe Owner Should Consider
Running a cafe is more than just serving delightful coffee and snacks; it's about creating an experience and ensuring that experience is safeguarded. While the hospitality industry can be incredibly rewarding, it's not without its risks. This is where the importance of insurance comes into play, acting as a crucial safety net for cafe owners. - read more


Your free hospitality insurance quote comparison starts here!
First Name:
Postcode:

All quotes are provided free and without obligation. We respect your privacy.

Knowledgebase
Public Liability Insurance:
Insurance which provides protection against liability to third parties.